Lab Grown vs Natural Coloured Stones
Quick Answer: Lab grown and natural gemstones are the same material. A lab-grown ruby is corundum with chromium in it, chemically and optically identical to a mined one; what differs is where the crystal grew, not what it is made of. Everything else follows from that — price, paperwork, and the wording on a listing. Any useful lab grown vs natural gemstones comparison has to separate the physics, which is nearly identical, from the market, which is not.

Most of the argument around this topic comes from two questions being mixed together: is the stone real, and is it worth the money. They have completely different answers, and neither one settles the other. We make moissanite and coloured stones in our own factory in Wuzhou for buyers in more than 100 countries, and this is where the conversation usually needs untangling.
The Word "Natural" Is Doing a Lot of Work
"Natural" is a statement about origin. It means the crystal formed in the earth without human involvement. It is not a quality grade and it is not a promise about colour, clarity or cut. A natural stone can be opaque, badly proportioned, or heavily treated, and still be perfectly natural.
The same limit applies in the other direction. "Lab grown" says nothing about quality either. It describes a growth process, and the result can be superb or mediocre depending on cut and how clean the rough was. Neither word tells you whether the stone is worth its price.
Same Crystal, Different Origin
Corundum is aluminium oxide. Whether it forms in a magma chamber over millions of years or in a crucible over a few weeks, the crystal lattice is the same, the refractive index is the same, the specific gravity is the same, and the hardness is 9 on the Mohs scale either way. There is no structural difference to find, which is why gem labs identify origin from trace evidence rather than from the material itself.
Moissanite is the clearest example in our own catalogue. Essentially all moissanite in jewelry is lab-created, because natural material arrives only in meteorites and is not commercially cuttable. We sell it at D colour and VVS1 clarity with a GRA card, and nobody describes it as a fake anything — it is a stone in its own right with its own properties.
Where They Actually Differ: Growth Evidence
What separates the two in a laboratory is the fingerprint of how the crystal grew. Natural corundum carries inclusions formed by its surroundings — silk, fingerprints, mineral crystals, growth zoning that follows the host rock's history. Lab-grown corundum tends to show curved growth striations, gas bubbles, or flux residues, depending on the method used.
None of that is visible reliably through a loupe, and some lab-grown stones are deliberately grown with inclusions to mimic natural material. Identification is a lab job with instrumentation, not a jeweller's guess at the counter. If origin matters to you, the answer is a report, not an opinion.
Price Logic: Supply, Not Quality
These two markets price on different things. A natural stone's price tracks the scarcity of rough at that quality — how rarely a clean, well-coloured crystal of that size comes out of the ground. A lab-grown stone's price tracks the cost of production capacity, and capacity has grown steadily, which is why lab-grown prices have fallen while the stones have not changed.
That is not an argument that lab-grown is worse value. It is an argument that the two prices answer different questions: one is a scarcity price, the other a manufacturing price. Comparing them on price alone compares a supply constraint to a production cost and calls the result "quality".
The Certificate Gap
Paperwork is not symmetrical either. Lab-grown diamonds are routinely graded by IGI. Our moissanite ships with a GRA card. Coloured stones, natural or lab-grown, often travel with nothing more than a vendor card, and many legitimate pieces below a certain value have no independent report at all.
So a certificate is not a quality ranking. It is a disclosure document: what the material is, what treatment it has had, and what the laboratory observed. Ask specifically what a card covers, and do not assume a piece without one is misrepresented.
Durability and Wear Are the Same
Because the material is the same, the wear behaviour is the same. A lab-grown sapphire at Mohs 9 scratches, chips and dulls at exactly the rate a natural sapphire does, and an emerald at 7.5 to 8 is equally vulnerable to knocks whichever way it formed. Hardness and cleavage follow the crystal structure, and the structure does not know where it grew.
This is the one area where the choice genuinely does not matter. If your concern is whether the ring will survive ten years of daily wear, origin is irrelevant and the setting is not.
Which Stones Have a Lab Version
Diamond, corundum in most colours, spinel, emerald, quartz and moissanite all have established lab-grown supply. Beyond that the picture is uneven: some varieties have thin or no commercial lab production, so if you want one particular rare colour you may only ever see natural stones, at natural prices.
How to Read a Listing
| What the listing says | What it establishes | What it does not |
|---|---|---|
| "Lab grown" | Origin: grown, not mined | Quality, cut, or colour grade |
| "Natural" | Origin: formed in the earth | Treatment, clarity, or value |
| "Certified" | A report exists on that stone | Which lab, or what it tested for |
| "D colour, VVS1" | A clarity and colour call | Cut quality or light performance |
| "Untreated" | A claim about treatment | Origin, or that the claim is verified |
What This Means for a Purchase
- Decide which question you are asking. If it is "will this look right and last", origin barely matters. If it is "is this what the seller says it is", you need a report.
- Do not pay a natural premium for a lab stone, and do not expect lab prices on natural goods. The gap between them is the whole point of the category.
- Judge cut before origin. A well-cut lab-grown stone outperforms a dull natural one every time, and cut is where most of the visual difference lives.
- Ask about treatment separately. Heat treatment is routine and stable; fracture filling affects how the piece must be cleaned, and that applies to both categories.

FAQ
Are lab grown gemstones fake?
No. They are the same crystal as the natural stone, grown under controlled conditions instead of in the ground. "Fake" describes a simulant — a different material imitating a gem — which is a separate category entirely.
Is lab grown vs natural gemstones a durability question?
It is not. Hardness, cleavage and toughness come from the crystal structure, which is identical. A lab-grown stone and a natural one of the same species wear the same way in the same setting.
Do lab grown stones come with certificates?
Sometimes. Lab-grown diamonds are commonly graded by IGI, and our moissanite ships with a GRA card. Coloured stones in either category often have only a vendor card, so check what a report actually covers.
Why are lab grown stones so much cheaper?
Because their price reflects production cost rather than the scarcity of rough. As growth capacity has expanded, prices have fallen. That is a supply story, not a quality story.
Can a jeweller tell the difference by eye?
Rarely and unreliably. The giveaway signs — curved growth lines, flux residue, gas bubbles — need magnification and often instrumentation. Treat any confident counter diagnosis as an opinion, not an identification.
Should I expect a lab grown stone to hold its value?
We would not frame any jewelry purchase that way. Buy a stone because you want to wear it; the resale market for both categories is narrow, and lab-grown prices in particular have moved downward over time.
Related: coloured stone jewellery and lab grown diamond jewellery.

